Mobile First vs. Responsive Website – Which One I Should Prefer
5 Sep 2016
Mobile First vs. Responsive Website – Which One I Should Prefer
Statistics are proofs that people tend to readily switch to other websites rather than boggling their brains with shrunken desktop versions and wasting time trying to adjust the websites with mobile by pinching, zooming and swiping them.
Things have gone mobile now. Who would prefer browsing websites over desktops and laptops when the same task can be easily done on mobiles? And this is what statistics suggest.
The point is very clear; you need to have a special strategy to combat the traffic that you gain from mobile devices.
And you are left with two solutions in order to meet the interests of your mobile users:
1. Have a responsive website design, also generally called as RWD
2. Have a mobile-first website
So which one should you choose? Each has its own pros and cons. Let’s discuss each of them in detail.
What Is A Responsive Website Design?
Responsive website designing is already making the headlines since months now. It is not a new concept but has evolved as a necessity only now.
Responsive website design is a way that allows your single site to cater the needs of a range of screen sizes – laptops, smartphones, tablets and others and adjusts its pixels accordingly with just one content source and one URL.
Speaking technically, it is a single HTML code that adapts itself to the varying needs of varied screen sizes on the basis of CSS media queries.
Responsive website design gained popularity when mighty Google recommended it as one of the factors influencing the website’s ranking in its recent update. And since then, websites with effective mobile experience are deemed to enjoy better search engine rankings than their counterparts. And this is when it all started!
How Responsive Web Design Works?
Responsive web design is a cumulative effort of three components that work in accordance to create amazing user experiences. These components include:
1. Flexible text and images
The flexible text and images adjust themselves as per the layout width set with CSS. This avoids overrunning texts that not only look shabby but also are hard to read. Flexible container ensures that the text is wrapped automatically and that the font size is adjusted on its own as per the requirement of the screen size.
2. A fluid grid
A fluid grid is responsible for adding scalability and flexibility to your web design. This makes sure that there is consistent spacing throughout based on percentages rather than using fixed pixels.
3. Media queries
Media queries adjust the page layout as per the viewport size. This might change from phone to phone. For one, content can come stacked in one column, while for other it can come in two equally spaced columns. The fonts might be smaller in one and larger in another.
Pros and Cons of Responsive Web Design
So which one should you choose to go for? This is a tough question indeed! Here is a quick breakup of RWD in terms of its pros and cons which would aid you in the decision-making process.
Pros
- Recommended by Google!
- Delivers better user experience to users browsing your website on smartphones and tablets
- Consistent brand experience delivered throughout a range of devices
- SEO friendly
Cons
- Higher load times, which can, however, be worked upon by employing smart tactics in place
- Takes time during design and development and testing phase
What Is A Mobile First Website?
A mobile first website is an approach that puts mobile first. It involves the design for smaller screens first and then the enhancement of mobile design for desktops and other big screens.
This design technique is also known as progressive enhancement. This results into a more focused and a clean design. Once the design is ready for mobile, it is easy to transform it to a PC design but is generally difficult the other way round.
This configuration makes use of different HTML for different devices, making use of 2 URLs.
Pros and Cons of Mobile First Website
Now that you know the basics of the mobile first website, let’s know more about the pros and cons of this approach in order to make a well-informed decision.
Pros
- This is a minimalistic way of designing where you take a minimum of everything from screen size to power.
- Easily creates a compact design which can then be leveraged and added more power in order to yield desktop version
- Faster to load and delivers flawlessly over mobiles
Cons
- You don’t get to see the desktop version of the site quickly
- You need to bear the cost of maintaining two websites – mobile website and desktop website
- You need to have two URLs, and this would mean double SEO work as well
- Too many bad redirects and high bounce rates, thus not-so-favorite of Google
Responsive Website Design vs Mobile Website
Well, the answer to this question to a large extent depends on your business goals. A business might choose to maintain both a desktop website and a mobile website or may choose to go smart and have a responsive web design that meets the needs of all devices with a single website. This basically is dependent on how big your project is, how much budget do you have allocated and how far you look forward to scaling your business.
The Final Line
If you own a business where you need to update content frequently, a responsive website design would be easier to manage and administer. Further, a responsive website design also earned more marks from Google, and thus is highly recommended.
